Guide for projects#
Summary#
The project component of Climatematch Academy is designed to guide you through the entire research process, from project ideation to presenting your outcome. Working with a group of 4-6 peers (or on your own), you will collaboratively develop a single research project over roughly two weeks of work, setting aside a few hours each day.
You will start by learning about good research practices by working on a ‘mock’ project through the lens of equity. You will then apply those skills to a scientific question and a geographical region that interests you and your teammates. To familiarize yourselves with the datasets at hand, you will examine the spatial and temporal distribution of one climate variable on global and local scales. After performing a brief literature review, you will develop a sense of interesting open questions in the field and will devise a specific testable hypothesis accordingly. You will then write a short project proposal and, ideally, get feedback on it from other people. Next, you will focus on acquiring evidence for or against your hypothesis. Finally, you will prepare a short presentation showcasing the story of your project.
The steps below are a suggested sequence, not a fixed timetable. Move through them at your own pace, and spend more time on the steps that matter most for your question.
You can also browse past projects to see what previous students accomplished.
Project Materials#
Choose one of the available project topics. Each project comes with an introductory video, a project template and a data loading jupyter notebook.
You will define their own research question. Project templates are maps of research ideas developed by the Climatematch Academy team. They are composed of GREEN, YELLOW, and RED questions in accordance with their difficulty. Each difficulty level is further divided into questions relating to a physical climate phenomenon (borderless) and those relating to socio-economic issues (dashed border). You should use this template as a guide and ideally come up with their own research question.
The templates should be used in several ways:
All teams must work through the GREEN questions as a first step. This will let you familiarize yourselves with the relevant datasets and appreciate the global variability of your selected climate phenomenon before defining your research question.
All teams must work on a research question related to a physical climate phenomenon, such as those proposed in the yellow and red boxes.
All teams are encouraged to consider the socio-economic impact of their climate phenomenon of interest (dashed border). We advise you to support your conclusions with data if it is possible.
If you are new to climate science or do not have a lot of research experience, we strongly recommend that you use the research questions provided in the template extensively. The templates have been designed to give you enough structure to get started and enough options to keep going. Comprehensively answering just one YELLOW or RED question from the template would be an achievement! You can pick the question that interests you the most right away without following the flow suggested by arrows on the template.
If you are an experienced climate researcher, you are more than welcome to branch out beyond the template and define your own research questions! However, we do ask you to stick to the climate datasets provided to you.
Project Time#
Plan for 2-3 hours of project work on each day you work on it. The goal during the first phase is to learn about the research process and develop a project idea. The goal of the second phase is to implement the analyses, interpret your findings, and present them.
Where possible, form a group with peers who share an interest in similar climate phenomena. We understand that specific interests and motivations will vary even within project groups, and being part of a team is as much about finding your role as it is about pursuing a specific personal research interest.
Alongside your project you can also take part in professional development activities, such as the Impact Talks on 1) climate justice, 2) equity in climate science, 3) open climate science, and 4) climate science communication. Please see the professional development section of the book for more details.
Step 1: Good Research Practices#
The goal of this step is to learn about the process of research design. To this end you will work through the tutorials on good research practices in your project groups.
Step 2: Guided Data Exploration and Initial Brainstorming#
The goal of this step is to get familiar with the dataset that you will work on your project. Each project team will choose one of the predefined templates according to their research interests. This project session is structured as follows:
(2 hrs) Explore one of the provided climate datasets from your chosen project template by working through the GREEN questions. Use the data loading notebook to get started and try to understand what is being done and why. Parts of this code might be reusable or adaptable later. Be on the lookout for interesting hypotheses and remember to work as a team! Ask for help, assist others, and discuss your findings throughout the day.
Apply the data wrangling skills you have acquired in tutorials thus far to generate the global maps suggested in Q1. Examine your plots. Do you notice any interesting patterns across the globe or over time?
Plot the global mean of the variable(s) over the time period suggested in Q2. Do you observe any trends? Does the result align with your expectations? Why? Why not?
As a group, agree on a geographical region to focus on and answer Q3. Depending on the variable you explore, choosing a continent, subcontinent, or small region might be appropriate choices. How does the result compare with your answer to Q2? Does this result align with your expectations? Why? Why not?
(1 hr) Brainstorm ideas for research questions.
(15 min) Start by discussing your initial project ideas! As a group, try to come up with one or a few questions of interest, either by yourselves or directly from the project template. Is there anything intriguing you noticed in the data? Are there any questions in the template you find particularly exciting?
(30 min) Start doing literature review using search engines like Google or Baidu. Look only at abstracts to select 2-3 promising ones. Revisit Step 2 of the tutorial on good research practices to review the literature more efficiently!
(15 min) Report to the whole group what papers you found and pool them together. Assign one paper per person to read/skim.
Step 3: Literature Review and Finalized Research Question#
The goal of this step is to complete the literature review and formulate the research question. The literature review aims to find out what is known or has been hypothesized about your climate phenomenon, determine what aspects are currently the most debated, and to help you define some keywords that you will use in your project proposal tomorrow. You do not need to come up with a completely original question! Do, however, situate your research within the relevant literature, and try to get hints/suggestions from other papers.
Conclude the literature review and define the research questions:
(1.5 hrs) On your own, read the paper that was assigned to you in the previous step. Make notes in a common google doc shared with your group, and especially write down important keywords or concepts which you might use in your project proposal. If you are interested in a closed-access paper and are not connected to an .edu domain or a VPN, try to find full versions of papers on preprint servers like arXiv or bioRxiv. You could also ask a librarian or colleague with institutional access to get it for you.
(30 min) Report back to the group. In ~5 minutes, try to tell them as much as you understand about the paper. Get into details, but do not just read whole sections from the paper out loud. Ask the other students questions about the papers they are presenting to understand them better.
(30 min) Discuss and synthesize information from the papers presented. Identify overlapping themes, concepts, or gaps in the research you have encountered. Based on these discussions, refine the initial questions the group came up with. Aim to narrow down to a primary research question that is specific, measurable, and relevant to the data and interests of the group.
(30 min) Formulate the research question and devise a hypothesis. Discuss as a group what they expect to discover or what predictions they can make based on their literature review and understanding of the data. This hypothesis should guide your project’s direction and the methods you will need to employ.
We encourage you to consider not only the physical science aspects of a climate phenomenon, but also its socio-economic impact. We understand that specific interests and motivations will vary even within project groups and becoming part of the Climatematch community is as much about finding your role in the team as it is about pursuing a specific personal research interest. Please consider your teammates interests and ideas with as much respect as your own.
Step 4: Proposal Writing and Feedback#
The goal of this step is to write your project proposal and get feedback on it.
(2 hrs) The first block of time will be spent preparing your proposal. The proposal can be a list of bullet points or a coherent paragraph; do not worry about the structure too much. The goal is to structure your thoughts and ideas so that a person unfamiliar with the topic can understand the importance of your research question and approach.
(30 min) By yourself, read Ten simple rules for structuring papers. Pay close attention to figure 1, and how it specifies the same overall structure for the abstract, for each paragraph in the paper, and for the paper as a whole.
(1.5 hrs) As a group, try to write a proposal for this project based on the way you understand it now, following the C-C-C scheme described in the Ten simple rules paper.
Context: scientific background and the knowledge gap your project will aim to fill. Include keywords and concepts that you identified in your literature review.
Content: your hypothesis and a description of the analyses and the results (positive or negative) you would need to answer your question.
Conclusion: the potential significance and societal impact of the work.
(1 hr) The remaining time will be used for refinement based on feedback from a proposal swap.
(30 min) It is always revealing to present your research to someone who has never heard about it. Share your proposal with another team (or another person, such as a colleague or friend) and ask for their feedback; if possible, review a proposal from them in return. In your group, read and discuss the other proposal and write down some feedback. What do you understand about their project? What do you not understand about it? When giving your feedback, keep in mind that the other research group has put a lot of effort into generating the proposal and may not have had time to polish the language or presentation of their ideas. We always aim to be direct and specific, but also polite, respectful, and kind in our communication with each other.
(30 min) Work to address the feedback you received and finalize your project proposal.
Step 5: Drafting the Analysis and Task Allocation#
The goal of this step is to draft the analysis framework and allocate tasks. You should now have a sense of the data, and you have probably refined your hypothesis a little. Writing your proposal will have helped you get a rough idea of what tools you might use to tackle your research question, and what the answer could look like. You will use the remaining project time to implement the analyses you have planned and make progress towards an answer. To this end, you should organize your time and plan accordingly. Keep in mind that your group might not be able to complete their research plan, but don’t get discouraged: answering a research question usually takes months if not years of work and you should consider making meaningful progress towards that goal a great success!
The following plan is suggested:
(40 min) Draft the analysis plan. Discuss the main methods and techniques to be used for analyzing the data. Consider different analytical approaches that could be applied and select the most appropriate ones for their specific data and questions. If you know what analysis you need but don’t know how to do it, look for documentation, tutorials, or example notebooks of the relevant toolkits.
(20 min) Divide the group into smaller teams or have them work individually based on their skills or areas of interest. Assign specific parts of the data analysis to each student or team, ensuring that everyone has a clear task that contributes to the overall project. Finally, create a timeline that includes specific dates for progress checks and integration points. Set specific goals for the remaining session.
(2 hrs) Start working on your project! A few pieces of general advice:
Leverage existing tools: Try not to implement complicated analyses from scratch. Use existing toolkits, and learn how to use them well. This kind of knowledge is very helpful long-term.
Focus on clear objectives: Keep your project goals clear and your activities aligned with achieving these goals. This helps in maintaining a direct path towards successful project outcomes.
Maintain simplicity: Start with simple analyses and build complexity as needed. This approach helps in early detection of potential data issues and allows for easier troubleshooting.
Step 6: Implementation#
You set the goal for this step!
(1 hr, optional) Professional Development - Impact Talk: Watch one of the Impact Talks with your group and hold a group discussion. The talks cover topics such as 1) climate justice, 2) equity in climate science, 3) open climate science, and 4) communication in climate science and can be found here.
(2 hrs) Continue working on your project!
If you find a negative answer to your question, that is absolutely ok! Please do report that. Then go back and think about how this affects your initial hypothesis. Does it rule it out, or could there be limitations in this particular data that lead to the negative result? What other data could you seek out that would be more well-suited for answering this question? Try to design a new experiment in specific details and tell us about it. Who knows, somebody might run that experiment someday!
If you find a positive result (i.e. the data matches your hypothesis), you should spend the rest of your time validating it to make absolutely sure it is a real effect. For example, if you created a proxy-based paleoclimate reconstruction of precipitation hydrogen isotopes (δD) to assess past changes in rainfall amount, there are a few factors you could consider to ensure that the climate signal in your data is real and reliable. Are the δD values in the part of your record closest to present similar to modern measurements of rainfall δD at your study site? Are there other factors in addition to your variable of interest (rainfall amount) that may be contributing to the δD signal in your data? Can you remove the effect of these other factors so that the dominant signal in your δD record is recording changes in rainfall amount?
Step 7: Continued Implementation#
What is your goal for this step?
Continue working on your project! A couple of extra pieces of general advice:
Collaborate effectively: Make sure to reconvene with your teammates every 1-1.5 hours to discuss your progress. If you are struggling with something, ask others for help right away! Use the course materials, library documentation, and your community as resources when your group gets stuck.
Document everything: Keep detailed records of your data analysis processes, decisions, and modifications. This practice is invaluable for revisiting your work and providing clear explanations during your project presentation.
Think about the impact: The later part of the course curriculum shifts from topics surrounding physical climate phenomena to issues of socio-economic impact as well as extreme events. This is a good point to start thinking about the impact the research topic you are studying as part of your project has on ecosystems and communities.
Step 8: Identifying Main Findings#
What is your goal for this step?
Continue working on your project and start thinking about what are your main findings. It is okay to feel short of time but do not feel discouraged. Below, some final advice for the last part of your project implementation:
Prioritize key tasks: Focus on the essential elements of your project that directly contribute to answering your research questions.
Prepare for contingencies: If something isn’t working as planned due to time constraints, focus on alternatives that can achieve similar outcomes within the available time.
Step 9: Interpreting Results#
The goal of this step is to interpret your results and identify conclusions.
Use this step to wrap up your main findings:
You can list these in bullet points and emphasize how they address the research questions or contribute to understanding the underlying problem. In case of any unexpected results, discuss with your group and theorize why they might have occurred. All results are valid!
Link your results to literature. Compare your findings with your reviewed literature. How do your results support, contradict or expand the current knowledge?
Based on the findings and their implications, draft your conclusions.
Step 10: Preparing Your Presentation#
The goal of this step is to communicate your results in a final presentation.
Tie up loose ends and prepare a short slideshow about your project!
(1 hr) Finalize visuals: Complete any graphs, charts, or visual aids that will be used in your presentation.
(2 hrs) Use this presentation template. Make a copy for your team to edit! You can add your group name and project title to the bottom panel of non-title slides through Slide -> Edit theme. Consider these suggestions:
Content : The 1 minute - 1 slide rule might seem like an impossible limit. However, it is one of the most useful formats you can learn, often referred to as a “one minute elevator pitch”.
Always have an introduction slide and a conclusion slide. If your group is relatively large (>=5 people), then someone should be assigned to each of the intro and conclusion slides. If your group is small, then the same person can present the intro + next slide, or conclusion slide + previous slide.
It’s completely normal if your group doesn’t achieve expected results. If this is true for your group, the main goal will be to explain the logic behind your project proposal. For instance, if you designed a project to compare climate datasets to analyze the impact of El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) on global temperatures, but couldn’t find the appropriate data to get answers, this is still valuable. In the case of this example, the takeaways from your project could potentially highlight the need for more temperature data from specific regions or time periods in order to assess ENSO variability. What got you excited about this particular project? What could your project evolve into if given more time and resources?
(1.5 hrs) The key to a good presentation is to practice it by yourself many times. It is no different from other performing arts (acting, playing a musical instrument etc), where rehearsals are crucial to a good performance.
Step 11: Presenting#
Present your project to others, such as other groups, colleagues, or friends. Keep in mind that your presentation is meant to be told as a story, and everyone from your group should take their turn in telling a part of that story. Tell us about the different hypotheses you have had at different points and how you refined them using some of the tools you learned during the course.
Presentation format#
Aim for about 5 minutes per group (depending on group size), followed by 1-2 minutes for questions.
One minute per person and one slide per person is a good rule of thumb.
Do not introduce yourselves again if everyone already knows each other; just present the material directly.
When you are done presenting, leave the last slide up (with conclusions), and open the floor for questions.
Discussion questions#
After presenting, use the following questions to guide a discussion. It’s ok not to use all of them, especially if you have your own questions to ask!
What was missing in the dataset that you would have really liked to have?
Which one of the steps of good research practices was hardest and why?
Based on your experience with the project, what project would you most like to do next? Make up your own, or pick from the other projects available in the course.
What surprised you the most about the process of working on a project? In what way was this project most different from other projects you have worked on in the past?
What technique did you learn in the course that you think you can immediately apply to your own project (if you are currently doing research)?
Questions#
If your presentation was short enough, there is time for questions from the audience. These are a great way to get feedback on your project!
Before you ask a question, consider whether others might be interested in that topic too. This usually means asking big picture questions, as opposed to detailed, technical questions, but there are exceptions.
If you are answering the question, try to be short and concise. Your audience will notice if you start rambling, and it can seem as if you are avoiding the question. Answering concisely is another very useful skill in “real life”. It also means that you can take more questions given our time constraints.